Simply Good Bakery
Baking has long been a passion in our family. Some of our recipes have been handed down through the generations. We make everything from scratch, never using a box cake or premade pie shells. We pick most of our fruit from local orchards and freeze them the day they are picked, capturing the best possible flavor the entire year. Many of our baked goods are in local coffeehouses and restaurants. Check out our contact page to find a hot spot that offers Simply Good along with those establishments regular menu.
Click titles for more information.
Cakes
All cakes are made from scratch, never from a box. Cakes are 9” round and 3 layers, unless otherwise stated. Price range is $40 - $50. All cakes can be made as cupcakes. Please call or email to place your order.
Amy’s Famous Carrot Cake, cream cheese icing
Lemon Blueberry Cake, light lemon buttercream
Italian Cream Cake, cream cheese pecan icing
Dark Chocolate Cake, chocolate, raspberry or vanilla buttercream, 10” round 2 layer. (Add chocolate, vanilla, raspberry or strawberry mousse for an additional charge.)
Red Velvet, light gob icing
German Chocolate
Hummingbird Cake, cream cheese icing
Coconut Cake, coconut buttercream
Great Grandma’s Christmas Cake, cranberry icing
Vanilla Bean Cake, whipped buttercream icing
Gingerbread Cake, Whipped buttercream icing
Pies
Our 10” pies are made from scratch this means never frozen or pre made pie crusts and our fillings never come from a can. Price range $18-$22
Apple, Peach, Blueberry, Triple, Berry, Coconut Cream, Banana, Chocolate, Lemon Meringue, Pecan, Egg Custard, Apple Cranberry, Pumpkin
English Muffins
Big, fluffy and full of nooks and crannies. Perfect with our homemade jams & jellies. Orders come in a half dozen and are priced from $8 to $12
Plain, Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, Cranberry Orange, Spent Grain, Sun dried tomato basil
Chocolate Fruit
We use Callebaut Belgian Chocolate, sold by the pound.
Chocolate covered fruit, dried fruit and nut bark made to order and truffles.
Cookies
Extra Large Coffeehouse Cookies – Sold by the half dozen. Prices vary from $8 to $12.
Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Crinkle Cookies, Oatmeal Raisin, Sugar, Molasses Ginger, Nut Twists, Apricot Twists.
Wedding and Grazing Table Cookies
A Southwestern PA tradition. Wedding cookies are sold by the pound and will include a variety of different cookies including the bride and grooms favorites. We will also include bags for guests to take cookies home.
Scones
Tender Flaky and delicious, just like a scone should be! We have sweet and savory options. Orders come in 8 and prices vary $18 to $24
Sweet – Lemon Blueberry, Cranberry Orange, Apple Pecan, Triple Berry, Chocolate, Lime, Coconut, Cherry Almond Savory – Bacon, Gruyere & Green Onion; Ham, Sweet Pepper & Cheddar; Ricotta & Herb; Dill Feta
Gobs
A western Pennsylvania favorite. Orders come in 6 and prices vary from $14 to $18. Flavors include Chocolate, Red Velvet, Pumpkin with Browned Butter Maple Filling, Vanilla w/Strawberry Muffins – XLarge.
Muffins
Extra Large! Orders come in a half dozen and are priced from $14 to $18
Banana Chocolate Chip & Walnut, Blueberry, Cherry Sour Cream, Apple Cider, Kiwi, Pumpkin & Chocolate Chip